Goyard vs Hermes: Which Luxury Bag Is Worth Buying?

You can buy a Goyard bag this afternoon. A Hermes bag might take months of refreshing a sold out product page and a long stretch of building a relationship with a sales associate. That gap is the real story behind Goyard vs Hermes, and it matters more than any spec sheet.

Both are Parisian houses, both make their bags in France with a lot of handwork, and both tend to hold their value better than most luxury brands. So which one is worth your money? My answer: buy Goyard if you want a great bag this month, and chase Hermes only if you can get one at retail and plan to keep it for years. Below I compare how hard each brand is to buy, what you’ll actually pay, craftsmanship, resale, and the models people really cross shop, the Goyard Musette and Anjou against the Hermes Evelyne and Picotin. Prices were checked in November 2026 and they change often, so confirm before you pay.

Goyard Anjou PM tote beside a Hermes Evelyne 16 crossbody bag for a Goyard vs Hermes comparison

(Image Credit : Goyard )

Goyard Bag vs Hermes Bag: The Short Verdict

Neither brand wins everywhere, but they win different fights. Here’s the scorecard.

What mattersGoyardHermesEdge
Easiest to buyBoutiques and its US websiteWebsite listings that sell out, plus boutiquesGoyard
Entry priceSaint Louis PM at around $1,900 to $2,000Evelyne 16 at $2,525Goyard
CraftsmanshipHand painted canvas, made in ParisHandmade leather, made in FranceTie
ResaleUsually close to retailOften above retail on in demand bagsHermes
Best forA lightweight, low key everyday bagA leather classic that picks up characterYour call

For most people I’d pick Goyard, for a boring reason: a great bag you can actually buy beats a legendary bag you can’t. Hermes only wins outright if you can get in at the retail price, and the resale section below shows why that one detail changes the whole math.

Can You Walk In and Buy One? Goyard vs Hermes Exclusivity

Goyard is the easier brand by a wide margin. You can walk into a boutique and ask for a core tote, and Goyard’s US website now sells bags directly too. When I pulled up the Saint Louis PM page, it showed the bag in stock with free express delivery and a 30 day online return window for plain bags. Personalized pieces, the ones with hand painted initials or stripes, can’t be returned. Older guides still say Goyard doesn’t sell online, so check the date on whatever you’re reading. Specific colors and sizes still come and go, so call ahead before you travel.

Hermes is a different experience. The Birkin and Kelly aren’t sold on Hermes’s website, and reporting on the Birkin antitrust lawsuit describes the most coveted bags as offered intermittently, usually to clients with a purchase history. Hermes has told the court there is no mandatory spending requirement, and a federal judge dismissed that case with prejudice in September 2025. The plaintiffs appealed, and The Fashion Law’s May 2026 report was the latest coverage I found, with the appeal still pending.

The Evelyne and Picotin are easier to want than to buy. I opened Hermes’s US page for the Evelyne 16 Amazone along with the Picotin Lock 18 listings, and every color I saw was either sold out or offering a button to be notified when it’s back. The price is right there on the page. The bag usually isn’t. So the real gatekeeping at the entry level is stock, not money.

That’s the trade. If you hate gatekeeping, Goyard wins this category easily. If the chase is part of the appeal for you, Hermes is built for exactly that, though I found it a lot less fun than it sounds.

Hermes Evelyne 16 Amazone product page showing the price and a notify me button because the bag is sold out

(Image credit : Hermes)

Goyard vs Hermes Price: What You’ll Actually Pay

Here are the models people really cross shop, with US prices checked in November 2026.

BagBrandUS priceWhere the number comes from
Saint Louis PMGoyardAbout $1,900 to $2,000Goyard’s US site and boutique reports
Musette PMGoyardAbout $2,570Reported by clients at the spring 2026 launch, not published by Goyard
Anjou PMGoyardAbout $3,180Reported boutique price, not published by Goyard
Evelyne 16 AmazoneHermes$2,525Hermes’s US site
Picotin Lock 18Hermes$3,975Hermes’s US site, Clemence leather

Two things to know. First, Goyard doesn’t publish most of its prices, so the Musette and Anjou figures come from clients and specialist reports. Ask a sales associate for the current number before you plan around it. Hermes does list the Evelyne and Picotin online, though a listed price and available stock are two different things. Second, the Birkin and Kelly sit in a much higher price tier and aren’t on Hermes’s website at all, so when people say Hermes costs only a little more than Goyard, they’re almost always talking about the Evelyne or Picotin.

At the bottom of each range the two brands are closer than their reputations suggest. A Musette PM and an Evelyne 16 are within about $50 of each other. The gap opens up as you move to bigger or more structured Hermes bags. If Louis Vuitton is the other name on your shortlist, I compared the totes head to head in Goyard vs Louis Vuitton.

Craftsmanship: Hand Painted Canvas vs Hermes Leather

Goyard starts with its canvas. Goyardine is a coated blend of linen, cotton and hemp, and the chevron pattern is painted by hand, which is a big reason the bags cost what they do. Everything is made in Paris. I broke down where the money goes in why Goyard is so expensive, but the short version is that the canvas is light, waterproof and hard to scuff. The Saint Louis weighs about 300 grams because it has no lining. The weak spot is the painted edges, which can chip on corners and straps.

Hermes goes the other way, with leather. Its own product pages describe the Evelyne 16 and Picotin Lock 18 as handmade in France, cut from taurillon Clemence leather and sewn without a lining. The Evelyne carries a perforated H, and Hermes ties that detail to the bag’s equestrian roots, when riders wore it against the body so their gear could dry. The Picotin adds a small lock closure borrowed from the Kelly.

I’d call craftsmanship a tie and decide on aging. Side by side, the Evelyne read like a piece of saddlery and the Musette read like a piece of gear. Goyard’s canvas shrugs off rain and scuffs, so it keeps looking new for a long time. Clemence leather is soft and grainy, which hides small marks, but it still scratches, darkens and softens with use. If you want a bag that resists wear, pick Goyard. If you want one that shows its years like a well worn saddle, pick Hermes.

Close up of Goyardine chevron canvas beside Hermes Clemence leather grain for a Goyard vs Hermes craftsmanship comparison

Resale Value: Which Bag Holds Up Better?

Goyard tends to hold close to retail. The Saint Louis PM resale listings I checked this autumn bracketed today’s retail price, and recent sold prices for the Anjou PM land right around its retail price too. That’s strong, but it isn’t a profit once you count fees. For more on which models keep their value, I wrote up whether designer bags hold their value.

Hermes is where resale gets strange. Sotheby’s puts pristine pre owned Evelyne 16 bags at roughly $3,500 to $4,000 against a $2,525 retail price, with rare colors going higher. The first time I set a resale Evelyne next to the Hermes retail page, I thought I’d misread the tab. That premium exists because most people can’t buy at retail, and it creates an odd result. Hermes only beats Goyard on value if you get in at the retail price. If you’re buying resale, you’re paying Hermes’s scarcity premium, and Goyard’s near retail pricing starts to look like the smarter purchase. I didn’t expect to land there when I started comparing the two, but it’s where the numbers pushed me.

If you plan to sell down the road, Fashionphile vs The RealReal compares what each platform pays once fees are counted. Condition, color and year will move your price more than the name on the tag.

Fakes: Where Each Brand Gets Copied

Both brands are counterfeited, and Goyard is heavily copied because the chevron pattern is so recognizable. The safest rule is the boring one. Buy new from the brand, and buy pre owned only from sellers that authenticate in house and offer a return window. If you’re eyeing a Goyard secondhand, the fake vs real Goyard guide walks through the canvas pattern, handles and hardware checks. Hermes fakes can be convincing too, so a suspiciously low price on any Evelyne or Picotin is a warning, not a deal.

Goyard Musette or Anjou vs Hermes Evelyne or Picotin

These are the matchups people actually search for, and each pair solves a different problem.

Goyard Musette PM vs Hermes Evelyne 16

This is the closest matchup in the whole comparison, and the fashion press spotted the resemblance right away when Goyard launched the Musette in spring 2026. Both are slim crossbody bags with a tab style closure and a strap you can wear short or long. The Musette PM is reported at about $2,570 in the US and comes in eleven Goyardine colors, with an adjustable leather strap, a magnetic closure and an inside pocket. The Evelyne 16 is $2,525 on Hermes’s site, closes with a leather tab and snap, uses a canvas strap, and measures 6.3 by 7.1 by 2.2 inches.

At 2.2 inches deep the Evelyne is slim: phone, cardholder, keys and not much else. The price is basically a wash. The difference is access and aura. The Evelyne is a cult classic that sells for more than retail secondhand, and the Musette is the one you can buy on a Tuesday. If I had to carry one this month, I’d carry the Musette. If I could get an Evelyne at retail, I’d take it without thinking.

Goyard Musette PM and Hermes Evelyne 16 worn crossbody side by side to compare size and strap length

Goyard Anjou PM vs Hermes Picotin Lock 18

These two don’t do the same job, which is worth knowing before you spend. The Anjou PM is a reversible tote, leather on one side and Goyardine on the other, and it’s a more structured option than the Saint Louis. It’s reported at about $3,180. The Picotin Lock 18 is a compact bucket bag at $3,975 on Hermes’s site, measuring 7.1 by 7.5 by 5.1 inches, unlined and closed with a small lock.

If you need a bag for a work day, the Anjou is the one that can actually carry it, and it costs about $800 less. The Picotin is a bag you buy for the shape, the lock and the name, and it holds far less. It’s also not a quota bag, which makes it one of the more reachable Hermes bags, though reachable doesn’t mean in stock.

Who Should Buy Goyard and Who Should Wait for Hermes

Buy Goyard if you want to carry something beautiful this month, you like a light bag that doesn’t announce itself, and you’d rather pay a known price than play a waiting game. Start with the Saint Louis for the classic, the Musette for a crossbody, or the Anjou when you want structure.

Wait for Hermes if you have the patience to build a relationship with a boutique, you love leather that ages, and you’re happy to buy at retail or not at all. Start with the Evelyne 16 or Picotin Lock 18, since they’re the most reachable bags in the lineup. Set restock alerts and visit boutiques. Hermes says no spending is required, so I wouldn’t buy things you don’t want in the hope that it helps. My blunt take: the most overrated thing about Hermes is the exclusivity, and the most underrated thing about Goyard is that you can simply buy it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you walk into a Goyard store and buy a bag?

Yes. Goyard sells through its own boutiques, and its US website also lists bags like the Saint Louis PM with free express delivery. Popular colors and sizes come and go, so call the boutique before you travel. Personalized pieces take two to four weeks and can’t be returned.

Is Goyard cheaper than Hermes?

At the entry level the two are close. A Saint Louis PM runs around $1,900 to $2,000 and the Musette PM is reported at about $2,570, against $2,525 for the Evelyne 16. Goyard’s Anjou PM, at around $3,180, still sits below the $3,975 Picotin Lock 18. The Birkin and Kelly sit in a much higher tier.

How can you tell if a Goyard bag is real?

Start with the chevron canvas. A hand painted pattern has depth and slight variation that machine prints struggle to copy, and the canvas weight, leather handles and hardware finish should all feel consistent. Buy pre owned only from sellers that authenticate, and ask for a return window.

Does Goyard hold its resale value?

Usually close to retail. Sold listings for the Saint Louis and Anjou land near their retail prices, which is strong for a bag you’ve actually carried. Hermes bags in high demand, like the Evelyne, can sell above retail, but that premium depends on condition, color and year.

Can you buy a Hermes bag online?

Some of them, yes. Hermes’s US website lists the Evelyne 16 and Picotin Lock 18 with prices, though stock is thin and many colors show a notify me button. The Birkin and Kelly aren’t sold on the website.

So Which One Is Worth Buying?

Goyard is the bag you can buy and enjoy this month. Hermes is the bag worth waiting for, but only if you can get it at retail. If you’re spending your own money on a normal timeline, I’d put a Goyard in your hands first, then decide whether the chase for a Hermes still sounds appealing once you’re carrying something great every day.

Before you commit to either one, read the Goyard guides above on price, fakes and resale. The checks you do before buying matter more than the name on the bag.

pinit fg en rect red 28

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top